Find The 1kg Watermelon A Mathematical Weighing Puzzle

by Admin 55 views

This is a classic mathematical puzzle that challenges your problem-solving skills. The problem presents a seemingly complex situation: you have 11 watermelons, each weighing between 1 and 11 kilograms, and a scale that breaks if you put anything heavier than 11 kg on it. The challenge? Find the 1 kg watermelon in just two weighings. This article will guide you through a step-by-step solution, offering insights into the mathematical principles at play and providing a clear, concise explanation that will help you understand the logic behind the solution.

Understanding the Problem

Before diving into the solution, it's crucial to fully grasp the problem's constraints and objectives. We have 11 watermelons, each with a unique weight from 1 kg to 11 kg. The goal is to identify the watermelon weighing 1 kg using a scale that can only handle a maximum weight of 11 kg. This limitation adds a layer of complexity, as we cannot simply weigh all the watermelons together. The puzzle requires a clever strategy to isolate the 1 kg watermelon within the given constraints. The key here is to break down the problem into smaller, manageable steps. By carefully selecting which watermelons to weigh together, we can narrow down the possibilities and ultimately pinpoint the 1 kg watermelon in just two weighings. This involves a bit of mathematical thinking and strategic planning.

Weighing Strategy and Logical Deduction

The solution lies in a strategic approach to weighing the watermelons. Instead of trying to weigh them all at once, we need to use a process of elimination. The first weighing will involve selecting a specific number of watermelons and placing them on the scale. The result of this weighing will provide us with crucial information about the possible location of the 1 kg watermelon. The second weighing will then be based on the outcome of the first, allowing us to further narrow down the possibilities and pinpoint the 1 kg watermelon. This method relies on logical deduction – using the information we gain from each weighing to make informed decisions about the next step. It's like a detective solving a case, using clues to eliminate suspects until only the true culprit remains. The beauty of this puzzle is that it showcases how mathematical thinking can be applied to real-world problems, even seemingly simple ones like finding a light watermelon.

The Two-Weighing Solution

Here’s how to solve this intriguing puzzle:

Step 1: The First Weighing – Divide and Conquer

  • Label the Watermelons: Start by labeling the watermelons from 1 to 11. This will help you keep track of them during the weighing process.
  • Divide into Groups: Divide the watermelons into three groups: Group A (watermelons 1, 2, 3, and 4), Group B (watermelons 5, 6, 7, and 8), and Group C (watermelons 9, 10, and 11).
  • First Weighing: Weigh Group A against Group B. This is the crucial first step that sets the stage for the rest of the solution. The outcome of this weighing will determine our next course of action. It's like a fork in the road, with each path leading to a different set of possibilities. This initial weighing is designed to provide us with maximum information, allowing us to narrow down the search for the 1 kg watermelon.

Step 2: Analyzing the First Weighing Outcome

The result of the first weighing will fall into one of three scenarios, each requiring a different approach for the second weighing:

  • Scenario 1: Group A = Group B: If the scale balances, it means the 1 kg watermelon is in Group C (watermelons 9, 10, or 11). This is because the weights in Group A and Group B are equal, so the light watermelon must be in the remaining group. This scenario immediately narrows down our search, eliminating eight watermelons from consideration. It's like finding a crucial piece of evidence that points us in the right direction.
  • Scenario 2: Group A < Group B: If Group A is lighter than Group B, the 1 kg watermelon is in Group A (watermelons 1, 2, 3, or 4). This is a straightforward deduction – the lighter group must contain the lighter watermelon. This outcome focuses our attention on a specific set of watermelons, allowing us to refine our search in the next weighing. It's like identifying a prime suspect in a mystery.
  • Scenario 3: Group A > Group B: If Group A is heavier than Group B, the 1 kg watermelon is in Group B (watermelons 5, 6, 7, or 8). This is the opposite of Scenario 2, but the logic is the same – the lighter group contains the lighter watermelon. This outcome, like Scenario 2, provides us with a clear direction for the next step, guiding us towards the potential location of the 1 kg watermelon.

Step 3: The Second Weighing – Pinpointing the 1 kg Watermelon

Now, let's see how the second weighing works in each of the scenarios:

  • Scenario 1: 1 kg Watermelon in Group C (9, 10, 11):
    • Weigh watermelons 9 and 10. This is a simple comparison to isolate the 1 kg watermelon.
      • If 9 < 10, then watermelon 9 weighs 1 kg.
      • If 9 > 10, then watermelon 10 weighs 1 kg.
      • If 9 = 10, then watermelon 11 weighs 1 kg (since we know the 1 kg watermelon is in Group C).
    • This weighing is a direct comparison, designed to quickly identify the 1 kg watermelon from the remaining possibilities. It's the final step in our detective work, leading us to the solution.
  • Scenario 2: 1 kg Watermelon in Group A (1, 2, 3, 4):
    • Weigh watermelons 1 and 2.
      • If 1 < 2, then watermelon 1 weighs 1 kg.
      • If 1 > 2, then watermelon 2 weighs 1 kg.
      • If 1 = 2, weigh watermelon 3 against watermelon 4. The lighter one weighs 1 kg.
    • This weighing follows a similar logic to Scenario 1, using comparisons to isolate the 1 kg watermelon. It's a systematic approach, ensuring that we don't miss any possibilities.
  • Scenario 3: 1 kg Watermelon in Group B (5, 6, 7, 8):
    • The process is the same as in Scenario 2, but you weigh watermelons 5 and 6. If they balance, weigh 7 against 8.
    • This scenario mirrors Scenario 2, applying the same logical steps to a different group of watermelons. It demonstrates the versatility of the solution, showing how the same approach can be used in different situations.

The Logic Behind the Solution

The beauty of this solution lies in its efficient use of information. By strategically dividing the watermelons into groups and using the first weighing to narrow down the possibilities, we significantly reduce the number of watermelons that need to be weighed in the second step. This divide-and-conquer approach is a common problem-solving technique in mathematics and computer science. It involves breaking down a complex problem into smaller, more manageable subproblems, solving each subproblem, and then combining the solutions to solve the original problem.

The first weighing provides us with crucial information about which group contains the 1 kg watermelon. This is a key step in the process, as it eliminates a significant portion of the watermelons from consideration. The second weighing then focuses on the remaining watermelons, using direct comparisons to pinpoint the 1 kg watermelon. This two-step process is designed to minimize the number of weighings required, while still guaranteeing a correct solution.

Why This Solution Works

This solution works because it leverages the power of logical deduction and systematic elimination. The first weighing provides a broad overview, narrowing down the search to a smaller subset of watermelons. The second weighing then uses a more precise method to identify the 1 kg watermelon within that subset. The combination of these two weighings ensures that we can find the 1 kg watermelon in just two steps, regardless of which watermelon it is.

The strategy is based on the principle of information gain. Each weighing provides us with information that reduces the uncertainty about the location of the 1 kg watermelon. By carefully selecting which watermelons to weigh, we maximize the information we gain from each weighing, leading us to the solution in the most efficient way possible.

Conclusion: The Elegance of Mathematical Problem-Solving

This watermelon puzzle is a fantastic example of how mathematical thinking can be used to solve real-world problems. It highlights the importance of strategic planning, logical deduction, and efficient use of information. The solution is elegant in its simplicity, requiring only two weighings to identify the 1 kg watermelon from a group of 11. This puzzle demonstrates that even complex problems can be solved with a thoughtful approach and a bit of mathematical insight. It's a reminder that mathematics is not just about numbers and equations, but also about problem-solving and critical thinking. By understanding the principles behind the solution, you can apply these skills to a wide range of challenges in your own life.

By using a divide-and-conquer approach and focusing on maximizing information gain with each weighing, we can solve this puzzle efficiently. The solution showcases the power of mathematical thinking in everyday scenarios, proving that even seemingly complex problems can be tackled with the right strategy.