If You Could Change One Thing About Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood, What Would It Be?

Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood (FMA/B) stands as a monumental achievement in the anime and manga world. Its intricate plot, captivating characters, and profound themes resonate with audiences across the globe. However, even masterpieces are subject to scrutiny, and fans often ponder what could have been improved or altered. This article delves into the heart of this question: What's one thing fans wish they could change about FMA/B? We'll explore various aspects of the series, from character development and plot points to pacing and animation, ultimately aiming to understand the nuanced perspectives of its devoted fanbase.

Delving into Character Arcs and Development

When discussing potential changes in FMA/B, character development frequently surfaces as a central theme. While the core cast, particularly the Elric brothers, undergoes significant transformations throughout the series, some fans feel that certain secondary characters could have benefited from more in-depth exploration. For instance, the character of Riza Hawkeye, a skilled marksman and Lieutenant in the Amestrian State Military, is undeniably compelling. However, her backstory and internal conflicts are not as thoroughly examined as some viewers might desire. Expanding on her relationship with Roy Mustang, her motivations, and her personal struggles could have added another layer of depth to the narrative. Similarly, characters like Olivier Armstrong, the formidable leader of Fort Briggs, possess immense potential for exploration. Although her strength and leadership are evident, a deeper understanding of her past and her personal philosophy could have enriched her character arc. Another aspect of character development that some fans critique is the treatment of certain antagonists. While villains like Father and the Homunculi are undeniably menacing, some argue that their motivations and backstories could have been fleshed out further. Understanding their origins, their goals, and their internal conflicts could have added complexity to their characters and made them more compelling antagonists. Furthermore, the relationships between the characters are a crucial aspect of FMA/B's narrative. The bond between Edward and Alphonse Elric is the emotional core of the series, but other relationships, such as the one between Winry Rockbell and the Elric brothers, or the camaraderie among the State Alchemists, could have been explored more extensively. Delving deeper into these dynamics could have enriched the emotional impact of the story and provided a more nuanced understanding of the characters' motivations and actions. In conclusion, while FMA/B boasts a cast of memorable and well-developed characters, the potential for further exploration and nuance is always present. By delving deeper into the backstories, motivations, and relationships of both protagonists and antagonists, the series could have achieved an even greater level of emotional depth and complexity.

Plot Pacing and Narrative Structure

The plot pacing and narrative structure of FMA/B are generally lauded for their effectiveness in delivering a compelling and engaging story. However, some viewers feel that certain sections of the series could have been paced differently, or that specific plot points could have been handled with more nuance. One common point of discussion is the early part of the series, which adapts the initial chapters of the manga. While this section is essential for establishing the characters and the world, some viewers find it to be slightly rushed, particularly for those who are already familiar with the original Fullmetal Alchemist anime series. A more deliberate pace in the early episodes could have allowed for a more gradual introduction to the complex themes and characters of the story. Conversely, some fans argue that the latter part of the series, particularly the final confrontation with Father, could have benefited from a more streamlined approach. While the climactic battle is undeniably epic in scale, some viewers feel that it becomes somewhat convoluted, with numerous characters and subplots vying for attention. A more focused narrative, with a clearer sense of progression towards the final resolution, could have heightened the emotional impact of the ending. Another aspect of the plot that some fans critique is the handling of certain subplots. While FMA/B excels at weaving together multiple storylines, some viewers feel that certain subplots are either underdeveloped or unresolved. For example, the Ishvalan Civil War is a crucial historical event that shapes the characters' motivations and the overall narrative, but some fans argue that it could have been explored in greater depth. Similarly, the stories of certain minor characters, such as those involved in the underground criminal network, could have been given more closure. Furthermore, the use of flashbacks and exposition is a key element of FMA/B's storytelling. While these techniques are generally effective in providing context and revealing character backstories, some viewers feel that they are occasionally overused, disrupting the flow of the narrative. A more judicious use of flashbacks and exposition could have maintained the pacing and momentum of the story. In summary, while FMA/B's plot pacing and narrative structure are generally well-executed, there are certain areas where adjustments could have been made. By carefully considering the pacing of different sections of the series, the handling of subplots, and the use of flashbacks and exposition, the narrative could have been further refined and optimized for maximum emotional impact.

Exploring World-Building and Lore

The world-building and lore of FMA/B are widely praised for their depth and intricacy. The fictional world of Amestris, with its unique blend of alchemy, military culture, and political intrigue, is a fascinating and immersive setting. However, even in a world as richly developed as this, there are aspects that some fans wish could have been explored further. One common desire is for a more in-depth examination of the history and culture of Amestris itself. While the series provides glimpses into the country's past, particularly through the Ishvalan Civil War, a more comprehensive exploration of its origins, its social structures, and its political dynamics could have added even more depth to the setting. Understanding the history of Amestris, its relationship with neighboring countries, and the evolution of its alchemical traditions could have provided a richer context for the events of the story. Similarly, the lore surrounding alchemy, the fundamental force that shapes the world of FMA/B, is a subject of great fascination for fans. While the series delves into the principles of equivalent exchange and the philosophical implications of alchemy, some viewers feel that there is still more to be explored. A deeper understanding of the different schools of alchemy, the history of alchemical research, and the potential limitations and dangers of this powerful art could have enriched the world-building and added a new layer of complexity to the narrative. Furthermore, the mythology and religious beliefs of Amestris are intriguing elements that are not fully explored in the series. The concept of the Gate of Truth, the mysterious realm that governs the flow of alchemical energy, is a recurring motif, but its true nature remains somewhat enigmatic. Similarly, the role of religion in Amestrian society, and the beliefs of its various religious groups, could have been examined in greater detail. By delving deeper into these aspects of the world-building, FMA/B could have created an even more immersive and believable setting. The potential for further exploration is vast, and fans often speculate about the untold stories and hidden secrets that lie within the world of Amestris. In conclusion, while FMA/B's world-building is already a significant strength, the opportunity to expand upon its history, culture, alchemy, and mythology could have made it even more compelling and memorable.

Animation Quality and Visual Style

The animation quality and visual style of FMA/B are generally considered to be top-notch, particularly for a series produced in 2009. The character designs are distinctive and expressive, the action sequences are fluid and dynamic, and the overall visual presentation is polished and professional. However, as with any animated series, there are always aspects that could be improved, or stylistic choices that some viewers might question. One common point of discussion is the consistency of the animation quality throughout the series. While the majority of episodes are visually impressive, there are occasional instances where the animation appears to be slightly less refined, particularly in scenes with large crowds or complex action sequences. Maintaining a consistently high level of animation quality can be a challenge for any production team, but addressing these occasional dips could have further elevated the visual impact of the series. Another aspect of the animation that some fans critique is the use of certain visual effects. While the alchemical transformations and energy blasts are generally well-animated, some viewers feel that they occasionally appear overly flashy or distracting. A more subtle and nuanced approach to these visual effects could have enhanced the overall aesthetic and prevented them from detracting from the story. Furthermore, the character designs, while generally well-received, are not universally praised. Some viewers find that certain characters, particularly some of the antagonists, could have benefited from more distinctive or menacing designs. A more visually striking portrayal of these characters could have added to their presence and impact on the story. In addition to the technical aspects of the animation, the visual style of FMA/B is also a matter of personal preference. While the series generally adopts a realistic and grounded visual approach, some viewers might have preferred a more stylized or exaggerated aesthetic. Exploring different visual styles could have given the series a unique visual identity and appealed to a wider range of viewers. In summary, while FMA/B's animation quality and visual style are generally strong, there are always opportunities for improvement and stylistic experimentation. By focusing on consistency, visual effects, character designs, and overall aesthetic, the series could have achieved an even greater level of visual excellence.

Addressing Minor Plot Holes and Inconsistencies

Even in a meticulously crafted narrative like FMA/B, minor plot holes and inconsistencies can occasionally arise. These are often small details that do not significantly detract from the overall story, but addressing them can enhance the believability and internal consistency of the world. One common type of plot hole involves inconsistencies in character abilities or motivations. For example, there may be instances where a character's actions seem to contradict their established personality or skillset. Addressing these inconsistencies can involve providing additional explanation for the character's behavior, or adjusting the narrative to better align with their established traits. Another type of plot hole involves inconsistencies in the world-building or lore. For example, there may be instances where the rules of alchemy, or the history of Amestris, seem to be violated. Resolving these inconsistencies can involve clarifying the established rules of the world, or retconning certain events to better fit the overall narrative. Furthermore, minor plot holes can sometimes arise from simple oversights or errors in continuity. For example, a character may appear in a scene where they were not previously established to be, or a piece of equipment may disappear and reappear without explanation. Addressing these errors can involve carefully reviewing the story for continuity issues and making minor adjustments to ensure consistency. While these minor plot holes and inconsistencies may seem insignificant on their own, addressing them can contribute to a greater sense of immersion and believability in the story. A narrative that is free from plot holes allows viewers to fully engage with the characters and the world, without being distracted by inconsistencies or unanswered questions. In conclusion, while FMA/B is a remarkably well-written and tightly plotted series, addressing minor plot holes and inconsistencies can further enhance its quality and impact. By carefully reviewing the story for these issues and making appropriate adjustments, the creators can ensure that the world of FMA/B remains consistent, believable, and fully engaging for its audience.

What Change Would You Make to Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood?

Ultimately, the question of what to change in FMA/B is a matter of personal preference. The series has resonated deeply with millions of viewers, and its enduring popularity is a testament to its quality and impact. However, by exploring the various aspects of the series that could potentially be improved, we can gain a deeper appreciation for its strengths and weaknesses. Whether it's character development, plot pacing, world-building, animation quality, or minor plot inconsistencies, there is always room for discussion and debate. What remains undeniable is that Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood has left an indelible mark on the anime landscape, a standard against which other series are often measured. The question isn't so much whether it's perfect, but rather, what makes it so beloved despite its minor flaws.