Movies With Subplots Better Than The Main Plot
It's a fascinating cinematic phenomenon when a movie's subplot unexpectedly overshadows its main plot, capturing the audience's imagination and leaving them yearning for more. These subplots, often rich in character development, intricate storylines, or thought-provoking themes, possess the potential to be compelling narratives in their own right. In some cases, they even outshine the central narrative, leaving viewers wondering what could have been if the filmmakers had chosen to explore these secondary stories further. This article delves into the realm of movies where the subplot held greater promise, examining instances where a shift in focus could have elevated the film to new heights.
The Allure of the Subplot
Before diving into specific examples, it's important to understand what makes a subplot so captivating. A compelling subplot typically offers a fresh perspective, introduces intriguing characters, or explores themes that resonate deeply with the audience. It can provide a welcome diversion from the main plot, offering moments of levity, introspection, or suspense. When a subplot truly shines, it adds layers of depth and complexity to the overall narrative, enriching the viewing experience and leaving a lasting impression.
Sometimes, a subplot's appeal lies in its emotional core. It might explore themes of love, loss, friendship, or self-discovery in a more nuanced way than the main plot allows. Other times, the subplot might offer a glimpse into a fascinating world or culture, providing a backdrop against which the main plot unfolds. Whatever the reason, a standout subplot has the power to captivate audiences and spark their imaginations.
The Potential of Unexplored Narratives
The beauty of a compelling subplot is that it often hints at a larger, more complex story waiting to be told. It might introduce characters with hidden depths, hint at unresolved conflicts, or raise intriguing questions that the main plot leaves unanswered. This potential for further exploration is what makes these subplots so tantalizing. Viewers are left to imagine the possibilities, envisioning how the story could have unfolded if the subplot had taken center stage.
In some cases, the subplot's potential might even surpass that of the main plot. The main plot might suffer from predictability, weak character development, or a lack of originality. In contrast, the subplot might offer a fresh take on familiar themes, introduce compelling new characters, or explore uncharted narrative territory. When this happens, it's natural for viewers to feel that the filmmakers missed an opportunity to create something truly special.
Examples of Movies with Subplots That Should Have Been the Focus
Let's explore some specific movies where the subplot arguably held more potential than the main plot, examining why these secondary narratives resonated with audiences and how they could have been developed into full-fledged stories.
1. Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind: The Relationship Between Patrick and Clementine
While the main plot of Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind revolves around Joel's experience with Lacuna, Inc. and his attempts to erase Clementine from his memory, the subplot involving Patrick, a Lacuna employee, and his obsession with Clementine offers a compelling counterpoint. Patrick's story, a tale of unrequited love and the dangers of manipulating memories, raises intriguing questions about identity, obsession, and the ethics of memory alteration. This subplot has a raw and vulnerable feel as it explores the nature of love. If the film had focused more on Patrick's perspective, it could have offered a more nuanced exploration of these themes.
Patrick's character, played with quiet intensity, is a complex and fascinating figure. He is both sympathetic and unsettling, a man driven by his desires but also haunted by his actions. His relationship with Clementine is a twisted reflection of Joel's, highlighting the dangers of idealizing a person and attempting to mold them into one's fantasy. Exploring Patrick's backstory, his motivations, and the consequences of his actions could have added a layer of psychological depth to the film, making it even more thought-provoking. The subplot's emotional core resonates with audiences because it deals with universal themes of love, loss, and the complexities of human relationships. Patrick's character, in particular, is a standout, as he embodies the tragic consequences of unrequited love and the dangers of obsession.
The subplot's themes of memory manipulation and identity also offer rich territory for exploration. By focusing on Patrick's perspective, the film could have delved deeper into the ethical implications of erasing memories and the potential for abuse. The subplot's pacing and character development are meticulously crafted, drawing viewers into Patrick's world and making them invested in his fate. The dialogue is sharp and insightful, revealing Patrick's inner turmoil and his struggles with his own identity. This focus on character-driven storytelling would have allowed for a more intimate and engaging narrative.
2. Raiders of the Lost Ark: Sallah's Story
In Raiders of the Lost Ark, Indiana Jones's quest for the Ark of the Covenant is the main plot, but Sallah's story, a complex character whose depth is only hinted at, deserves greater exploration. Sallah, an Egyptian excavator and a friend of Indy, plays a crucial role in the film, but his background, motivations, and personal struggles remain largely unexplored. A film focusing on Sallah could delve into the political landscape of Egypt in the 1930s, the cultural tensions between Egyptians and colonial powers, and Sallah's personal journey as he navigates these complexities. Sallah's resourcefulness and his deep knowledge of Egyptian culture make him a compelling character in his own right. By shifting the focus to Sallah, the film could have offered a fresh perspective on the adventure genre, exploring themes of cultural identity, colonialism, and the clash between tradition and modernity.
Such a film could explore the rich tapestry of Egyptian culture and history, providing a backdrop for Sallah's personal journey. The political tensions of the time, with Egypt under British influence, could have been a central theme, adding layers of complexity to the narrative. Sallah's character could have been developed further, revealing his motivations, his fears, and his hopes for the future. His relationships with his family and community could have been explored in greater depth, adding an emotional dimension to the story. The challenges Sallah faces in a society grappling with colonial influences and political unrest would make a compelling narrative. His role as a bridge between cultures could be explored in greater detail, highlighting his diplomatic skills and his understanding of different perspectives. The film could also delve into Sallah's knowledge of archaeology and his passion for preserving Egypt's cultural heritage.
This subplot's potential lies in its ability to offer a more nuanced and culturally sensitive perspective on the adventure genre. By focusing on Sallah's experiences, the film could have challenged the traditional Western-centric view of adventure and explored the complexities of cross-cultural interactions. The themes of cultural preservation and the clash between tradition and modernity are particularly relevant in today's world. Focusing on Sallah's character and his unique perspective would have allowed for a richer and more meaningful exploration of these themes.
3. The Lord of the Rings: The Story of the Ents
While the main plot of The Lord of the Rings trilogy centers on the Fellowship's quest to destroy the One Ring, the story of the Ents, the ancient tree-like beings of Fangorn Forest, offers a fascinating subplot with its own compelling narrative arc. The Ents, led by Treebeard, are guardians of the forest, deeply connected to the natural world and possessing immense wisdom and power. Their story, a tale of loss, longing, and the slow awakening of ancient forces, could have formed the basis of a separate, equally captivating film. The Ents' unique perspective on time and their deep connection to nature set them apart from the other characters in Middle-earth. The Ents' deliberate and thoughtful nature provides a refreshing contrast to the fast-paced action of the main plot. Their struggle to make decisions and their eventual decision to join the war against Saruman is a powerful metaphor for the importance of taking action, even when it is difficult.
A film focused on the Ents could delve deeper into their history, their culture, and their relationship with the natural world. The loss of the Entwives, the female Ents, is a central theme in their story, and exploring this loss in greater detail could have added an emotional dimension to the narrative. The Ents' perspective on the events of the War of the Ring, seen through their ancient eyes, would offer a unique and thought-provoking perspective on the story. Their interactions with other creatures of Middle-earth, such as the Elves and the Hobbits, could have been explored further, highlighting their role as guardians of the forest and their deep understanding of the interconnectedness of all living things. The slow and deliberate nature of the Ents' actions would allow for a more contemplative and character-driven narrative.
The subplot's themes of environmentalism and the importance of preserving nature are particularly relevant in today's world. By focusing on the Ents, the film could have explored these themes in greater depth, highlighting the importance of protecting the natural world and the consequences of its destruction. The subplot's rich mythology and its unique characters make it a prime candidate for a standalone film. The story of the Ents is a timeless tale of loss, longing, and the awakening of ancient forces. A film focused on the Ents would have the potential to be both visually stunning and emotionally resonant.
4. Star Wars: Episode III – Revenge of the Sith: The Rise of the Rebellion
In Star Wars: Episode III – Revenge of the Sith, the main plot focuses on Anakin Skywalker's fall to the dark side and the rise of the Galactic Empire. However, the subplot detailing the formation of the Rebel Alliance, spearheaded by figures like Bail Organa, Mon Mothma, and Padmé Amidala, offers a glimpse into the seeds of resistance against the Empire. This subplot could have been expanded into a compelling narrative of its own, exploring the political maneuvering, the moral dilemmas, and the sacrifices made by those who dared to oppose Palpatine's tyranny. The subplot has a strong political undercurrent, highlighting the challenges of building a resistance movement in the face of overwhelming power. The moral dilemmas faced by the rebel leaders, as they grapple with the consequences of their actions, would add depth and complexity to the narrative.
A film focused on the rise of the Rebel Alliance could delve into the political landscape of the galaxy under Palpatine's rule, showcasing the growing discontent and the various factions that united to form the Rebellion. The challenges faced by the rebel leaders, as they navigate the treacherous political waters and build a coalition of diverse groups, would make for a compelling story. The personal sacrifices made by these individuals, as they risk their lives and their freedom to fight for a better future, could be explored in greater depth. The film could also showcase the early battles between the rebels and the Empire, highlighting the courage and determination of the rebel fighters. The story of the Rebel Alliance is a story of hope and resilience in the face of overwhelming odds. A film focused on this subplot would have the potential to be both thrilling and inspiring.
This subplot's potential lies in its ability to explore the themes of resistance, freedom, and the fight against tyranny. By focusing on the rise of the Rebel Alliance, the film could have offered a more nuanced and politically charged perspective on the Star Wars universe. The subplot's focus on political intrigue and moral dilemmas would provide a refreshing contrast to the action-oriented main plot. The story of the Rebel Alliance is a testament to the power of hope and the importance of standing up for what is right, even in the face of overwhelming odds.
The Art of Subplot Selection
Choosing the right subplot to elevate is a delicate balancing act. It requires filmmakers to identify the narratives that resonate most deeply with audiences, those that offer fresh perspectives, explore compelling themes, or introduce intriguing characters. It also requires a willingness to take risks, to deviate from the expected path, and to trust that the subplot has the potential to carry the weight of the main plot. Ultimately, the decision to focus on a subplot is a creative one, guided by vision, instinct, and a desire to tell the most compelling story possible.
The key to a successful subplot adaptation lies in developing the characters, expanding the world, and exploring the themes in greater depth. This requires careful planning, thoughtful writing, and a commitment to creating a narrative that is both engaging and meaningful. The subplot must be able to stand on its own, with its own unique identity and its own compelling story arc. The characters must be well-developed, with their own motivations, their own flaws, and their own personal journeys. The world must be richly detailed, with its own history, its own culture, and its own unique challenges. The themes must be explored in a nuanced and thought-provoking way, leaving the audience with something to ponder long after the credits have rolled.
Conclusion
The phenomenon of subplots outshining main plots is a testament to the power of storytelling. It highlights the importance of crafting compelling characters, exploring resonant themes, and offering fresh perspectives. While the main plot often serves as the foundation of a movie, it is the subplots that can truly elevate it, adding depth, complexity, and emotional resonance. By recognizing the potential of these secondary narratives, filmmakers can unlock new creative possibilities and create films that leave a lasting impact on audiences. The examples discussed in this article demonstrate the diverse ways in which subplots can capture the imagination and offer a richer cinematic experience. As viewers, we are left to ponder the endless possibilities and imagine the stories that could have been, reminding us that sometimes, the most compelling narratives are found in the unexpected corners of a film.
