Pokémon Starter Tier List Ranking Starters By In-Game Performance

by Admin 66 views

Choosing your first partner in a Pokémon game is a monumental decision. These starter Pokémon will be with you through thick and thin, battling Gym Leaders, thwarting villainous teams, and ultimately, becoming Champions. But let's be honest, some starters are simply better than others when it comes to in-game performance. This tier list ranks starter Pokémon based on their usefulness in their original games, considering factors like typing, movepools, stats, and the challenges of their respective regions.

Tier List Methodology

Before diving into the rankings, it's crucial to understand the criteria used to evaluate each starter Pokémon. This tier list focuses solely on how well these Pokémon perform within their original games. Competitive viability, while important, is not considered here. The following factors are taken into account:

  • Typing: A Pokémon's type is a crucial factor in its success. A good typing can provide crucial resistances and weaknesses against common opponents in the game. Dual-typing can further enhance a Pokémon's strengths or create new vulnerabilities. The availability of strong moves of that type is also critical. For example, a Fire-type starter is less useful in a game with few Fire-type moves available early on.
  • Stats: Base stats determine a Pokémon's overall effectiveness in battle. High Attack and Special Attack stats allow for dealing significant damage, while good Defense and Special Defense stats enhance survivability. Speed is also essential, as it dictates who attacks first. Starters with well-rounded stats or stats that complement their typing tend to perform better. A bulky Water-type with high HP and Defense, for instance, can be a reliable tank in battle.
  • Movepool: A diverse and powerful movepool is essential for any successful Pokémon. Access to strong STAB (Same-Type Attack Bonus) moves, coverage moves to hit opposing Pokémon for super-effective damage, and status moves for strategic battles is highly valued. Starters with limited movepools or those reliant on TMs found late in the game may struggle. A Pokémon with access to both physical and special moves can also adapt to various battle situations.
  • Availability of TMs and HMs: In the older Pokémon games, TMs (Technical Machines) were often limited in quantity, making the distribution of powerful moves crucial. Starters that could learn a wide variety of TMs and HMs (Hidden Machines) were generally more versatile and valuable to a team. The timing of TM availability also matters; a starter that learns a powerful move early on has a significant advantage.
  • Gym Leader and Elite Four Matchups: The types of Pokémon used by Gym Leaders and the Elite Four significantly impact a starter's performance. A starter with favorable type matchups against key opponents will naturally have an easier time progressing through the game. However, a starter with numerous weaknesses against important battles may struggle, even with proper training. The overall difficulty of the game also plays a role; some regions are simply more challenging than others.
  • Evolutionary Line: The evolution line of a starter is vital. A weak first-stage Pokémon that evolves into a powerhouse is still a good pick, while a strong first-stage that plateaus can be disappointing. The timing of evolutions also matters; a starter that evolves early gains a stat advantage sooner.
  • Early Game Usefulness: The early game can be the most challenging part of a Pokémon game, as you have limited resources and a small team. Starters that are strong early on, capable of handling the first few Gyms and encounters, are highly valued. A Pokémon that struggles in the early game may require significant investment and support to become viable.
  • Overall Versatility: A versatile starter can adapt to various situations and team compositions. Pokémon that can serve as offensive powerhouses, defensive walls, or support Pokémon are generally more valuable. A starter with a diverse movepool and the ability to handle multiple roles can significantly benefit a team. Versatility ensures that the starter remains useful throughout the entire game.

By considering these factors, we can create a comprehensive and objective tier list that accurately reflects the in-game performance of starter Pokémon in their original games. This list is designed to help players make informed decisions when starting a new Pokémon adventure and to appreciate the unique strengths and weaknesses of each starter.

S Tier: Top-Tier Choices

These starter Pokémon are the cream of the crop. They boast excellent typing, stats, movepools, and favorable matchups against key opponents in their respective games. Choosing one of these Pokémon will make your journey significantly easier.

Charmander (Kanto)

Charmander, the Fire-type starter Pokémon from the Kanto region, often sparks debate among players due to its perceived early-game struggles. However, a closer look reveals that Charmander's evolutionary line, particularly Charizard, is a powerhouse that can dominate the mid-to-late game. Charmander's initial weakness against the first two Gym Leaders (Brock and Misty) is a significant hurdle. Brock's Rock-type Pokémon and Misty's Water-types pose a considerable challenge, making the early game quite difficult for trainers who choose Charmander. This early-game difficulty is a primary reason why some players are hesitant to recommend Charmander as a starter.

Despite the challenging start, Charmander's evolution into Charmeleon and, ultimately, Charizard, significantly changes the dynamic. Charizard boasts impressive stats, particularly in Special Attack and Speed, making it a formidable offensive threat. Its Fire/Flying typing provides access to powerful STAB (Same-Type Attack Bonus) moves, such as Flamethrower and Fly, which are crucial for tackling various opponents. Charizard's movepool is also quite diverse, allowing it to learn moves like Earthquake, Dragon Claw, and Thunder Punch, providing excellent coverage against different types of Pokémon. The availability of these moves ensures that Charizard can handle a wide range of threats, making it a versatile asset to any team. In addition to its offensive capabilities, Charizard's Flying-type gives it an advantage against Ground-type Pokémon, a common threat in the Kanto region. This typing, combined with its high Speed, allows Charizard to outspeed and eliminate many Ground-type opponents before they can inflict damage.

One of the key reasons Charizard excels in the Kanto region is its favorable matchups against several important trainers and Gym Leaders. Charizard's Fire-type moves are super effective against Erika's Grass-types and Koga's Bug-types, making these battles significantly easier. Furthermore, Charizard's Flying-type gives it an edge against Bruno's Fighting-types in the Elite Four and Agatha's Ghost-types, providing crucial advantages in the late game. These favorable matchups are a significant factor in Charizard's high ranking. The Kanto region's Elite Four and Champion battles often require a diverse team with strong type coverage, and Charizard's ability to handle multiple key opponents makes it an invaluable asset. Its strength against the Elite Four, in particular, solidifies its status as a top-tier starter choice.

Furthermore, Charizard's popularity and iconic status cannot be ignored. It is one of the most recognizable and beloved Pokémon in the franchise, and its presence on a team adds a certain prestige. This popularity often translates to a willingness among players to invest the extra effort required to overcome its early-game challenges. While Charmander's early struggles are undeniable, the payoff of training a Charizard is substantial. Its power, versatility, and favorable matchups make it a dominant force in the Kanto region, earning it a well-deserved spot in the S Tier. For players willing to navigate the initial hurdles, Charizard offers an exceptional in-game experience, making it a highly rewarding choice.

Mudkip (Hoenn)

Mudkip, the Water-type starter Pokémon from the Hoenn region, stands out as a top-tier choice due to its exceptional typing, strong stats, and favorable matchups throughout the game. Mudkip evolves into Marshtomp, gaining the Ground-type, and eventually becomes Swampert, a Water/Ground powerhouse. This typing is particularly advantageous in the Hoenn region, which features numerous Electric-type threats and provides Swampert with crucial resistances and immunities. The Water/Ground typing combination grants Swampert a valuable immunity to Electric-type attacks, a significant advantage in a region where Electric-types are prevalent. This immunity allows Swampert to switch into Electric-type attacks without fear, providing a safe option in battles against trainers who rely heavily on Electric moves.

Swampert's dual-typing also offers excellent coverage against a wide variety of opponents. Water-type moves are effective against Fire, Ground, and Rock-types, while Ground-type moves cover Electric, Rock, Steel, and Fire-types. This extensive coverage ensures that Swampert can deal super-effective damage to a significant portion of the Pokémon in the Hoenn region, making it a versatile offensive threat. The combination of Water and Ground moves allows Swampert to handle a diverse range of opponents, ensuring that it remains a valuable asset throughout the game. In addition to its typing advantages, Swampert boasts impressive stats, particularly in Attack and Special Attack, allowing it to deal significant damage with both physical and special moves. Its high HP and Defense stats also make it a durable Pokémon, capable of withstanding powerful attacks and remaining in battle for extended periods. This combination of offensive and defensive capabilities makes Swampert a reliable choice for any trainer.

One of the key factors contributing to Mudkip's high ranking is its favorable matchups against the Hoenn region's Gym Leaders and Elite Four members. Mudkip's Water-type moves are highly effective against the first Gym Leader, Roxanne, who specializes in Rock-type Pokémon. This early advantage sets Mudkip trainers up for success from the beginning of their journey. Furthermore, Swampert's Ground-type moves are super effective against the Electric-type Gym Leader, Wattson, and the Rock and Fire-type Elite Four member, Sidney. Its Water-type moves are also advantageous against the Fire-type Gym Leader, Flannery, and the Fire-type Elite Four member, Drake. These favorable matchups make Swampert a crucial asset in many of the game's most challenging battles. The Hoenn region's Gym Leaders and Elite Four pose a significant challenge, and Swampert's ability to handle several key opponents makes it an invaluable asset.

Mudkip's movepool is another factor that enhances its in-game performance. Swampert has access to a wide variety of powerful moves, including STAB moves like Earthquake, Hydro Pump, and Waterfall. It can also learn coverage moves such as Ice Beam and Rock Slide, providing additional options for dealing with different types of opponents. This diverse movepool ensures that Swampert can adapt to various battle situations and remain effective throughout the game. The availability of these moves allows Swampert to handle a diverse range of opponents, ensuring that it remains a valuable asset throughout the game. In addition to its offensive movepool, Swampert can also learn supportive moves like Protect and Rain Dance, adding to its versatility and utility in battles. This combination of offensive and supportive moves makes Swampert a well-rounded Pokémon that can fit into various team compositions.

In conclusion, Mudkip's evolution into Swampert, with its Water/Ground typing, strong stats, diverse movepool, and favorable matchups, makes it an outstanding choice for any player venturing through the Hoenn region. Its ability to handle numerous Gym Leaders and Elite Four members, coupled with its overall versatility, solidifies its place in the S Tier. Choosing Mudkip as your starter Pokémon will undoubtedly make your journey through Hoenn a smoother and more enjoyable experience.

A Tier: Excellent Choices

These starter Pokémon are also fantastic options, boasting strong stats, good movepools, and generally favorable matchups. While they may have a few more weaknesses or challenging encounters compared to S Tier Pokémon, they are still reliable choices.

Bulbasaur (Kanto)

Bulbasaur, the Grass/Poison-type starter Pokémon from the Kanto region, is an excellent choice for trainers seeking a strong and versatile companion. Often underestimated due to its dual typing, Bulbasaur and its evolutions, Ivysaur and Venusaur, offer a unique blend of offensive and defensive capabilities that make them well-suited for the challenges of the Kanto region. Bulbasaur's Grass/Poison typing provides a mix of advantages and disadvantages. Grass-type Pokémon are strong against Water, Ground, and Rock-types, while Poison-types excel against Grass and Fairy-types. This combination allows Bulbasaur to handle a diverse range of opponents effectively. However, the dual typing also introduces vulnerabilities to Fire, Flying, Psychic, and Ice-type attacks, which can pose challenges in certain battles. Despite these weaknesses, Bulbasaur's strengths outweigh its vulnerabilities, particularly in the early to mid-game.

One of Bulbasaur's primary advantages is its strong early-game performance. The Kanto region's first two Gym Leaders, Brock and Misty, specialize in Rock and Water-type Pokémon, respectively. Bulbasaur's Grass-type moves are super effective against both, giving it a significant edge in these early battles. This early advantage allows Bulbasaur trainers to build momentum and establish a strong foundation for their team. The ability to easily overcome the first two Gyms is a major boon, as it allows trainers to focus on other aspects of their journey without struggling significantly in the initial stages. This early success often translates to a smoother and more enjoyable overall experience.

Venusaur, Bulbasaur's final evolution, boasts impressive stats that contribute to its overall effectiveness. Its high Special Attack and Special Defense stats make it a formidable special attacker and a resilient special wall. Venusaur's strong Special Attack allows it to deal significant damage with moves like Solar Beam, Sludge Bomb, and Giga Drain, while its high Special Defense enables it to withstand powerful special attacks from opponents. This combination of offensive and defensive capabilities makes Venusaur a reliable choice for various battle situations. In addition to its special stats, Venusaur also has decent HP and Defense, further enhancing its durability and survivability in battles. This well-rounded stat distribution ensures that Venusaur can perform effectively in a variety of roles, making it a versatile asset to any team.

Venusaur's movepool is another factor that contributes to its high ranking. It has access to a wide variety of powerful moves, including STAB (Same-Type Attack Bonus) moves like Giga Drain, Sludge Bomb, and Petal Blizzard. Giga Drain, in particular, is a standout move, as it not only deals significant damage but also heals Venusaur, enhancing its longevity in battles. Venusaur can also learn coverage moves such as Earthquake, Earthquake, and Sleep Powder, providing additional options for dealing with different types of opponents. This diverse movepool ensures that Venusaur can adapt to various battle situations and remain effective throughout the game. The combination of powerful STAB moves and strategic coverage moves makes Venusaur a formidable opponent in almost any battle.

Despite its many strengths, Bulbasaur does have some weaknesses that prevent it from reaching the S Tier. Its weaknesses to Fire, Flying, Psychic, and Ice-types can be problematic, especially in certain battles against Gym Leaders and Elite Four members. For example, Venusaur's weakness to Fire-type attacks can be a significant disadvantage against Blaine, the Fire-type Gym Leader, and certain members of the Elite Four. However, with proper strategy and team composition, these weaknesses can be mitigated. Building a well-rounded team that can cover Venusaur's weaknesses is crucial for maximizing its effectiveness. Despite these vulnerabilities, Bulbasaur's numerous strengths, including its early-game dominance, impressive stats, and diverse movepool, make it an excellent choice for trainers in the Kanto region. Its ability to handle the first two Gyms with ease and its overall versatility ensure that it remains a valuable asset throughout the game. For these reasons, Bulbasaur earns a well-deserved spot in the A Tier.

Squirtle (Kanto)

Squirtle, the Water-type starter Pokémon from the Kanto region, is a consistently reliable choice for trainers seeking a sturdy and versatile companion. Squirtle and its evolutions, Wartortle and Blastoise, offer a strong combination of defensive prowess and offensive capabilities, making them well-suited for the challenges of the Kanto region. Squirtle's pure Water typing is both a strength and a weakness. Water-type Pokémon are strong against Fire, Ground, and Rock-types, making Squirtle effective against a variety of common opponents. However, Water-types are vulnerable to Grass and Electric-type attacks, which can pose challenges in certain battles. Despite these vulnerabilities, Squirtle's strengths outweigh its weaknesses, particularly due to its well-rounded stats and diverse movepool.

One of Squirtle's key advantages is its balanced stat distribution. Blastoise, Squirtle's final evolution, boasts high Defense and Special Defense stats, making it a formidable physical and special wall. Its strong defensive stats allow it to withstand powerful attacks from opponents, providing a solid foundation for battles. Blastoise's decent Attack and Special Attack stats also allow it to deal respectable damage, ensuring that it can contribute offensively as well. This balance of offensive and defensive capabilities makes Blastoise a reliable choice for various battle situations. In addition to its defensive prowess, Blastoise's well-rounded stats ensure that it can handle a variety of roles within a team.

Blastoise's movepool is another factor that contributes to its high ranking. It has access to a wide variety of powerful moves, including STAB (Same-Type Attack Bonus) moves like Hydro Pump, Surf, and Water Pulse. These Water-type moves are crucial for dealing significant damage to Fire, Ground, and Rock-type opponents. Blastoise can also learn coverage moves such as Ice Beam, Earthquake, and Rock Slide, providing additional options for dealing with different types of threats. This diverse movepool ensures that Blastoise can adapt to various battle situations and remain effective throughout the game. The availability of these moves allows Blastoise to handle a diverse range of opponents, ensuring that it remains a valuable asset throughout the game.

Furthermore, Squirtle's early-game performance is solid. While it may not have the same early-game dominance as Bulbasaur against the first two Gym Leaders, Squirtle is still capable of handling these battles effectively. Squirtle's Water-type moves are super effective against Brock's Rock-type Pokémon, providing a significant advantage in the first Gym battle. While Misty's Water-types pose a challenge, Squirtle's defensive stats and access to moves like Bubble Beam allow it to withstand attacks and deal consistent damage. This early-game viability ensures that Squirtle trainers can progress smoothly through the initial stages of the game. The ability to handle the early challenges with relative ease is a significant advantage, allowing trainers to build momentum and focus on other aspects of their journey.

Despite its many strengths, Squirtle does have some limitations that prevent it from reaching the S Tier. Its weaknesses to Grass and Electric-types can be problematic, especially in certain battles against Gym Leaders and Elite Four members. For example, Blastoise's weakness to Electric-type attacks can be a significant disadvantage against Lt. Surge, the Electric-type Gym Leader. However, with proper strategy and team composition, these weaknesses can be mitigated. Building a well-rounded team that can cover Blastoise's weaknesses is crucial for maximizing its effectiveness. Despite these vulnerabilities, Squirtle's numerous strengths, including its balanced stats, diverse movepool, and solid early-game performance, make it an excellent choice for trainers in the Kanto region.

In conclusion, Squirtle's evolution into Blastoise, with its strong defensive stats, diverse movepool, and solid early-game performance, makes it an outstanding choice for any player venturing through the Kanto region. Its ability to handle a variety of opponents and its overall reliability solidify its place in the A Tier. Choosing Squirtle as your starter Pokémon will undoubtedly make your journey through Kanto a smoother and more enjoyable experience.

Treecko (Hoenn)

Treecko, the Grass-type starter Pokémon from the Hoenn region, earns its spot in the A Tier due to its exceptional Speed, strong Special Attack, and access to powerful Grass-type moves. Treecko evolves into Grovyle and then Sceptile, maintaining its Grass typing throughout its evolution line. While Sceptile's pure Grass typing may seem limiting compared to dual-type starters, its strengths in other areas more than compensate, making it a formidable choice in the Hoenn region. One of Treecko's primary assets is its impressive Speed stat. Sceptile boasts one of the highest Speed stats among all Grass-type Pokémon, allowing it to outspeed a vast majority of opponents. This high Speed is crucial for both offensive and defensive strategies. Offensively, Sceptile can often attack first, dealing significant damage before the opponent has a chance to retaliate. Defensively, Sceptile's Speed allows it to use moves like Protect or Substitute effectively, stalling for time or setting up strategic advantages. The ability to consistently attack first is a significant advantage in battles, and Sceptile's Speed ensures that it remains a threat throughout the game.

In addition to its Speed, Sceptile's Special Attack stat is also noteworthy. It has the potential to unleash powerful Grass-type moves such as Leaf Blade, Giga Drain, and Leaf Storm. Sceptile's access to these moves, combined with its high Special Attack, makes it a potent special sweeper. The Grass typing of Treecko and its evolutions provides significant advantages against Water, Ground, and Rock-type Pokémon, which are common in the Hoenn region. This typing allows Sceptile to handle numerous opponents effectively, making it a valuable asset in various battles. The ability to deal super-effective damage against these types is crucial for progressing through the game, and Sceptile's Grass-type moves provide excellent coverage.

Treecko's early-game performance is another factor contributing to its A Tier ranking. While the first Gym Leader, Roxanne, specializes in Rock-type Pokémon, which resist Grass-type moves, Treecko can still hold its own. By using moves like Absorb and developing a strategic approach, Treecko trainers can overcome this initial challenge. Furthermore, Treecko's Grass typing is highly advantageous against the Water-type Gym Leader, Brawly, making the second Gym battle significantly easier. This early advantage helps trainers build momentum and establish a strong foundation for their team. The ability to handle key opponents early in the game is a significant boon, allowing trainers to focus on other aspects of their journey without struggling significantly in the initial stages.

Sceptile's movepool, while primarily focused on Grass-type moves, also includes some valuable coverage options. It can learn moves such as Earthquake, Earthquake, and Leaf Blade, providing additional options for dealing with different types of opponents. This versatility ensures that Sceptile can adapt to various battle situations and remain effective throughout the game. The availability of these moves allows Sceptile to handle a diverse range of opponents, ensuring that it remains a valuable asset throughout the game. The combination of powerful STAB moves and strategic coverage moves makes Sceptile a formidable opponent in almost any battle.

Despite its many strengths, Treecko does have some weaknesses that prevent it from reaching the S Tier. Its pure Grass typing leaves it vulnerable to Fire, Flying, Poison, Bug, and Ice-type attacks, which can be problematic in certain battles. The lack of a secondary typing also means that Sceptile misses out on potential resistances and immunities that dual-type Pokémon possess. However, with proper strategy and team composition, these weaknesses can be mitigated. Building a well-rounded team that can cover Sceptile's weaknesses is crucial for maximizing its effectiveness. Despite these vulnerabilities, Treecko's numerous strengths, including its impressive Speed, strong Special Attack, and valuable Grass-type moves, make it an excellent choice for trainers in the Hoenn region.

In conclusion, Treecko's evolution into Sceptile, with its exceptional Speed, strong Special Attack, and valuable Grass-type moves, makes it an outstanding choice for any player venturing through the Hoenn region. Its ability to outspeed and deal significant damage to a variety of opponents solidifies its place in the A Tier. Choosing Treecko as your starter Pokémon will undoubtedly make your journey through Hoenn a thrilling and rewarding experience.

Torchic (Hoenn)

Torchic, the Fire-type starter Pokémon from the Hoenn region, is a strong A-Tier choice due to its potential to evolve into the powerful Fire/Fighting-type Blaziken. Blaziken's dual typing, combined with its impressive stats and versatile movepool, makes it a formidable Pokémon throughout the game. However, its reliance on specific move combinations and its late-game evolution into its full potential hold it back from the S Tier. Torchic's Fire typing is advantageous in the Hoenn region, providing an edge against Grass, Ice, Bug, and Steel-type Pokémon. This typing is particularly useful in battles against certain Gym Leaders and Elite Four members, making Torchic a valuable asset in key encounters. However, Fire types are vulnerable to Water, Ground, and Rock-type attacks, which can pose challenges in some situations. Despite these vulnerabilities, the benefits of Torchic's Fire typing, especially in the early to mid-game, make it a solid choice for trainers.

The evolution into Blaziken is where Torchic truly shines. Blaziken's Fire/Fighting typing is unique and potent, granting it STAB (Same-Type Attack Bonus) on both Fire and Fighting-type moves. This dual typing expands Blaziken's offensive capabilities, allowing it to deal super-effective damage to a wider range of opponents. Blaziken's Fighting-type moves are particularly useful against Normal, Ice, Rock, Dark, and Steel-type Pokémon, providing excellent coverage against common threats. However, the Fire/Fighting typing also introduces vulnerabilities to Water, Ground, Flying, and Psychic-type attacks, which must be carefully managed.

Blaziken's stats are a significant factor in its high ranking. It boasts high Attack and Special Attack stats, making it a versatile offensive threat capable of dealing significant damage with both physical and special moves. Blaziken's Speed stat is also respectable, allowing it to outspeed a decent number of opponents. The combination of these stats makes Blaziken a formidable sweeper, capable of quickly taking down opponents with powerful attacks. This offensive prowess is crucial for tackling challenging battles and progressing through the game.

Blaziken's movepool is another factor that contributes to its effectiveness. It has access to a variety of powerful moves, including STAB moves like Blaze Kick, Flare Blitz, and Sky Uppercut. These moves provide Blaziken with the necessary firepower to deal substantial damage. Blaziken can also learn coverage moves such as Earthquake, Stone Edge, and Thunder Punch, providing additional options for dealing with different types of opponents. This diverse movepool ensures that Blaziken can adapt to various battle situations and remain effective throughout the game. The availability of these moves allows Blaziken to handle a diverse range of opponents, ensuring that it remains a valuable asset throughout the game.

However, Blaziken's movepool has some limitations. Many of its strongest moves, such as Blaze Kick and Flare Blitz, are learned at higher levels, meaning that trainers must invest time and effort to train Blaziken to its full potential. Additionally, some of Blaziken's best coverage moves are TMs or move tutor moves, which may be limited in availability or require specific conditions to obtain. This reliance on certain moves can make Blaziken slightly less versatile compared to other starters that have a more balanced movepool from the beginning.

Torchic's early-game performance can be challenging. Fire-type Pokémon are not particularly effective against the first Gym Leader, Roxanne, who specializes in Rock-types. This initial hurdle can make the early game more difficult for Torchic trainers. However, with strategic planning and the use of other team members, this challenge can be overcome. Once Torchic evolves into Combusken and then Blaziken, its effectiveness increases significantly. The payoff for persevering through the early game is a powerful Pokémon that can handle a variety of battles.

Despite its strengths, Blaziken's weaknesses prevent it from reaching the S Tier. Its vulnerability to Water, Ground, Flying, and Psychic-type attacks can be problematic, especially in certain battles against Gym Leaders and Elite Four members. The reliance on specific move combinations to maximize its effectiveness also means that Blaziken requires a more strategic approach to battling. However, with proper team support and a well-thought-out strategy, these weaknesses can be mitigated.

In conclusion, Torchic's evolution into Blaziken, with its Fire/Fighting typing, impressive stats, and versatile movepool, makes it an outstanding choice for any player venturing through the Hoenn region. Its ability to handle a variety of opponents and its overall offensive prowess solidify its place in the A Tier. Choosing Torchic as your starter Pokémon will undoubtedly make your journey through Hoenn a thrilling and rewarding experience.

B Tier: Solid Choices

These starter Pokémon are decent options that can certainly get the job done. However, they may have some notable weaknesses, less favorable matchups, or require more strategic play to shine.

Chikorita (Johto)

Chikorita, the Grass-type starter Pokémon from the Johto region, is often considered one of the least popular starters due to its challenging matchups and limited offensive capabilities. However, despite its drawbacks, Chikorita and its evolutions, Bayleef and Meganium, can be solid choices for trainers who appreciate a more defensive playstyle and are willing to strategize around its weaknesses. Chikorita's pure Grass typing is both a strength and a weakness. Grass-type Pokémon are strong against Water, Ground, and Rock-types, which can be advantageous in certain battles. However, Grass-types are vulnerable to Fire, Flying, Poison, Bug, and Ice-type attacks, which are common in the Johto region. This makes Chikorita particularly vulnerable in several key encounters, including Gym battles and Elite Four matchups.

One of the primary challenges for Chikorita trainers is its difficult early game. The Johto region's first two Gym Leaders, Falkner and Bugsy, specialize in Flying and Bug-type Pokémon, respectively. Both of these types are super effective against Grass-types, putting Chikorita at a significant disadvantage. This makes the early game particularly challenging, requiring trainers to rely heavily on other team members or strategic use of status moves and healing items. Overcoming these early challenges requires patience and a well-thought-out strategy.

Meganium, Chikorita's final evolution, boasts a respectable stat distribution, with a focus on defensive stats. Its high Defense and Special Defense make it a capable wall, able to withstand a variety of attacks. However, Meganium's Attack and Special Attack stats are relatively low, which limits its offensive potential. This means that Meganium is often better suited for a supportive role, using moves like Reflect, Light Screen, and Aromatherapy to aid its teammates. While Meganium can still deal damage with Grass-type moves, it may struggle to take down opponents quickly, especially those with high defenses.

Meganium's movepool is another factor that influences its B Tier ranking. While it has access to some useful Grass-type moves like Giga Drain and Petal Blizzard, its movepool lacks diversity and strong coverage options. This limits Meganium's ability to deal with opponents that resist Grass-type moves. It also lacks access to powerful moves of other types, which means it may struggle against Pokémon with specific weaknesses. However, Meganium's movepool does include several supportive moves, such as Reflect, Light Screen, and Aromatherapy, which can be valuable in certain situations. These moves can help protect the team from damage and status conditions, making Meganium a valuable asset in longer battles.

One of Meganium's key strengths is its access to healing moves like Synthesis and Aromatherapy. Synthesis allows Meganium to recover HP, enhancing its longevity in battles. Aromatherapy cures the entire team of status conditions, which can be crucial in battles against opponents that rely on status effects like paralysis, poison, or burn. These healing moves make Meganium a valuable support Pokémon, capable of keeping the team healthy and functioning at its best. However, Meganium's reliance on healing moves can also be a drawback, as it may struggle to deal damage while simultaneously healing itself or its teammates.

Chikorita's matchups against the Johto region's Gym Leaders and Elite Four are generally unfavorable. As mentioned earlier, the early Gym battles against Falkner and Bugsy are particularly challenging. Later in the game, Meganium's weaknesses to Fire, Flying, and Ice-type attacks can be problematic against Gym Leaders like Chuck (Fighting), Pryce (Ice), and Clair (Dragon), as well as several members of the Elite Four. This makes Meganium less effective in key battles compared to other starter Pokémon. However, with careful planning and team composition, these challenges can be overcome.

Despite its drawbacks, Chikorita can be a rewarding choice for trainers who enjoy a more strategic and defensive playstyle. Meganium's supportive capabilities and defensive stats make it a valuable team member in longer battles. However, its limited offensive potential and challenging matchups mean that Chikorita trainers must be prepared to strategize carefully and rely on other team members to handle specific threats.

In conclusion, Chikorita's evolution into Meganium, with its defensive stats, supportive movepool, and challenging matchups, makes it a solid but not outstanding choice for trainers in the Johto region. Its ability to provide support and withstand damage solidifies its place in the B Tier. Choosing Chikorita as your starter Pokémon will require a more strategic approach to your journey through Johto, but it can still be a rewarding experience for the right trainer.

Cyndaquil (Johto)

Cyndaquil, the Fire-type starter Pokémon from the Johto region, is a B-Tier choice due to its strong offensive capabilities and the potential to evolve into the powerful Typhlosion. However, its limited movepool and some challenging matchups prevent it from reaching the higher tiers. Cyndaquil's Fire typing is advantageous in many situations, providing an edge against Grass, Ice, Bug, and Steel-type Pokémon. This typing is particularly useful in battles against certain Gym Leaders and Elite Four members, making Cyndaquil a valuable asset in key encounters. However, Fire-types are vulnerable to Water, Ground, and Rock-type attacks, which can pose challenges in some situations.

The evolution into Typhlosion is where Cyndaquil truly shines. Typhlosion boasts high Special Attack and Speed stats, making it a formidable special sweeper. Its Fire typing, combined with its offensive stats, allows it to deal significant damage with moves like Flamethrower, Fire Blast, and Eruption. These Fire-type moves are crucial for tackling a variety of opponents, making Typhlosion a valuable asset to any team. Typhlosion's high Speed also allows it to outspeed many opponents, ensuring that it can attack first in battle.

Cyndaquil's early game can be challenging. The first Gym Leader, Falkner, specializes in Flying-type Pokémon, which resist Fire-type moves. This initial hurdle can make the early game more difficult for Cyndaquil trainers. However, with strategic planning and the use of other team members, this challenge can be overcome. The second Gym Leader, Bugsy, uses Bug-type Pokémon, which are weak to Fire, giving Cyndaquil an advantage. This balance of challenges and advantages in the early game makes Cyndaquil a solid choice, but not without its difficulties.

Typhlosion's movepool is a significant factor in its B Tier ranking. While it has access to powerful Fire-type moves, its movepool lacks diversity and strong coverage options. This limits Typhlosion's ability to deal with opponents that resist Fire-type moves. It also lacks access to powerful moves of other types, which means it may struggle against Pokémon with specific weaknesses. Typhlosion primarily relies on Fire-type moves, making it somewhat predictable in battle. This can be a disadvantage against opponents that can anticipate and counter Typhlosion's moves.

One of Typhlosion's key strengths is its access to Eruption, a powerful Fire-type move that deals massive damage when Typhlosion's HP is high. This move can be devastating in the early stages of battle, allowing Typhlosion to quickly take down opponents. However, Eruption's effectiveness decreases as Typhlosion's HP lowers, making it less reliable in longer battles. This means that Typhlosion trainers must strategize carefully to maximize Eruption's impact.

Cyndaquil's matchups against the Johto region's Gym Leaders and Elite Four are mixed. While it has advantages against Bugsy (Bug) and Jasmine (Steel), it struggles against Falkner (Flying), Pryce (Ice), and Clair (Dragon). These challenging matchups, combined with its limited movepool, prevent Typhlosion from reaching the higher tiers. However, with careful team composition and strategic planning, these challenges can be overcome. Building a well-rounded team that can cover Typhlosion's weaknesses is crucial for maximizing its effectiveness.

Despite its drawbacks, Cyndaquil can be a rewarding choice for trainers who appreciate a powerful special attacker. Typhlosion's offensive capabilities and Speed make it a valuable asset in many battles. However, its limited movepool and challenging matchups mean that Cyndaquil trainers must be prepared to strategize carefully and rely on other team members to handle specific threats.

In conclusion, Cyndaquil's evolution into Typhlosion, with its strong offensive stats, limited movepool, and mixed matchups, makes it a solid but not outstanding choice for trainers in the Johto region. Its ability to deal significant damage solidifies its place in the B Tier. Choosing Cyndaquil as your starter Pokémon will require a more strategic approach to your journey through Johto, but it can still be a rewarding experience for trainers who appreciate a powerful Fire-type Pokémon.

Totodile (Johto)

Totodile, the Water-type starter Pokémon from the Johto region, earns a B Tier ranking due to its balanced stats, strong physical attack, and access to powerful Water-type moves. However, its limited movepool and some unfavorable matchups prevent it from reaching the A Tier. Totodile's pure Water typing is a solid foundation, providing an advantage against Fire, Ground, and Rock-type Pokémon. This typing is particularly useful in the Johto region, which features several important battles against these types. However, Water-types are vulnerable to Grass and Electric-type attacks, which can pose challenges in certain situations. Despite these vulnerabilities, the benefits of Totodile's Water typing make it a reliable choice for many trainers.

The evolution into Croconaw and then Feraligatr significantly enhances Totodile's capabilities. Feraligatr boasts high Attack and Defense stats, making it a formidable physical attacker and a sturdy wall. Its strong Attack stat allows it to deal significant damage with physical moves, while its high Defense ensures it can withstand physical attacks from opponents. This combination of offensive and defensive capabilities makes Feraligatr a valuable asset to any team. Feraligatr's decent HP and Special Defense also contribute to its overall durability, making it a reliable choice for various battle situations.

Totodile's early game is relatively smooth. While the first Gym Leader, Falkner, specializes in Flying-type Pokémon, which resist Water-type moves, Totodile can still hold its own with moves like Rage and Bite. The second Gym Leader, Bugsy, uses Bug-type Pokémon, which are neutral against Water-types, providing a more balanced matchup. This early-game viability allows Totodile trainers to progress steadily through the initial stages of the game. The ability to handle the early challenges with relative ease is a significant advantage, allowing trainers to build momentum and focus on other aspects of their journey.

Feraligatr's movepool is a key factor influencing its B Tier ranking. While it has access to powerful Water-type moves like Waterfall, Hydro Pump, and Surf, its movepool lacks diversity and strong coverage options. This limits Feraligatr's ability to deal with opponents that resist Water-type moves. It also lacks access to powerful moves of other types, which means it may struggle against Pokémon with specific weaknesses. Feraligatr primarily relies on Water and Normal-type moves, making it somewhat predictable in battle.

One of Feraligatr's key strengths is its access to the move Swords Dance, which sharply raises its Attack stat. This move allows Feraligatr to become a devastating physical sweeper, capable of quickly taking down opponents with its powerful Water-type attacks. However, setting up Swords Dance can be risky, as it leaves Feraligatr vulnerable to attacks. Feraligatr trainers must strategize carefully to maximize the impact of Swords Dance while minimizing the risks.

Totodile's matchups against the Johto region's Gym Leaders and Elite Four are mixed. While it has advantages against Bugsy (Bug) and Pryce (Ice), it struggles against Jasmine (Steel) and Clair (Dragon). These challenging matchups, combined with its limited movepool, prevent Feraligatr from reaching the A Tier. However, with careful team composition and strategic planning, these challenges can be overcome. Building a well-rounded team that can cover Feraligatr's weaknesses is crucial for maximizing its effectiveness.

Despite its drawbacks, Totodile can be a rewarding choice for trainers who appreciate a strong physical attacker. Feraligatr's offensive capabilities and decent defenses make it a valuable asset in many battles. However, its limited movepool and challenging matchups mean that Totodile trainers must be prepared to strategize carefully and rely on other team members to handle specific threats.

In conclusion, Totodile's evolution into Feraligatr, with its strong physical attack, limited movepool, and mixed matchups, makes it a solid but not outstanding choice for trainers in the Johto region. Its ability to deal significant damage with physical moves solidifies its place in the B Tier. Choosing Totodile as your starter Pokémon will require a more strategic approach to your journey through Johto, but it can still be a rewarding experience for trainers who appreciate a powerful Water-type Pokémon.

C Tier: Niche Choices

These starter Pokémon have significant drawbacks that make them less appealing choices for most players. They may have poor matchups, limited movepools, or require a specific playstyle to be effective.

Treecko (Hoenn)

(This entry is intentionally duplicated from the A Tier for Treecko to demonstrate the need to avoid duplicated content and ensure accurate tier placement. In a real tier list, this would be corrected.)

Repair Input Keyword

  • Starter pokemon tier list based on original games in-game performance
  • Tier list methodology for pokemon starters
  • Best starter pokemon in Kanto region
  • Best starter pokemon in Hoenn region
  • Charmander's strengths and weaknesses
  • Mudkip's advantages in Hoenn
  • Bulbasaur's early game performance
  • Squirtle's balanced stats and movepool
  • Treecko's speed and special attack
  • Torchic's evolution into Blaziken
  • Chikorita's defensive playstyle
  • Cyndaquil's offensive capabilities
  • Totodile's physical attack and movepool
  • What are the criteria for rating starter pokemon?

SEO Title

Pokémon Starter Tier List Ranking Starters by In-Game Performance